Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 January 2012

Film #21 - Sherlock Series 2 (2012)

Note: For all those unaware, the general rules for the 365 in 365/366 in 366 challenge are that one full series/season of a television show may also be counted as one off the list from your film list. So occasionally, I may manage to watch a show the whole way through it's run without giving up.


When BBC's latest Sherlock adaptation turned up in 2010, I don't remember expecting all that much of it. I hadn't really heard much of it, I hadn't bothered to look up buzz about it, I can't even remember why I tuned in. I'm glad I did however, as when I did what I found was one of the best shows currently on the magic box. There are just so many things to admire about this show, first of all it's bravery. In an age where it seems every show feels the need to talk down to you and generally treat you like an idiot, Sherlock trusted you to work things out for yourself. Of course there are many moments of explanation (could any of us keep up with Sherlock's mind?), but it never feels the need to indulge itself by explaining obvious plot points.

For any of this bravery to work out you'd actually need some smart scripts, which this series luckily has plenty of. Steven Moffat, Mark Gatiss and Steve Thompson all appear to have an astounding talent at revamping Arthur Conan Doyle's stories to not only fit the modern world and it's technological advancements, but also making adjustments where justified to make the stories feel somewhat more legitimate. For a real good show of revamping an old and dusty classic, treat yourself to Mark Gatiss' fresh reimagining of Holmes and Watson's most popular adventure: The Hound Of The Baskervilles.

However, the greatest strength of all in my opinion is the casting, with seriously strong performances throughout making everyone else on telly feel just a bit silly in their period drama costumes. Benedict Cumberbatch is Sherlock, forget Robert Downey Jr's slapstick and flirtatious failure of an attempt, Holmes should be a cold and calculated machine and this is exactly what you get with Cumberbatch. Martin Freeman on the other hand grows on you more and more as Watson, Holme's faithful sidekick and the human heart beating at the centre of all these mysteries. The greatest treat of all this series though, was getting to know Andrew Scott's Moriarty so much better. Unhinged, unpredictable and unnerving Scott portrayed everything you want Moriarty to be and more. Given glimpses of him in both the finale of the first series and the opener of the second, it wasn't until tonight's incredible finale too it all that we finally got to truly encounter him for all that he is. In fact, if you really want too know what I'm talking about when it comes to the acting department then please skip to the final episode of Series 2 for (in a more justifiable world) award winning performances from all three main players of the cast. Trust me, Martin Freeman as Watson may just make you shed a few tears towards the end of the final act.

As for the themes present in this series, I feel like this is the writers truly gaining confidence. While the first series was introducing us to their modern day interpretations of both the characters and crimes of the Sherlock Holmes world, this series is them striding in and leaving their own big footprint of how they want it to be done. Throughout the three feature-length episodes this series, there appears to of been a theme of Sherlock's relationships with those close too him. Despite nearly always appearing to be so cold on the outside, we occasionally see these little glimmers of emotions felt for those he cares about most. His anger when he finds someone to of harmed Mrs Hudson, his moments of laughter with Watson and his sad look of realisation when Molly suggests herself to be seen as nothing by him.

Overall, this series has once again proven that the BBC, at it's best, can produce programming like no other channel in the UK can at present. With sharp writing, incredible casting and a mature treatment of it's audience Sherlock manages to stand head over shoulders above the rest of our current schedules. Watch this now, and join me in my demands that Series 3 starts next Sunday.

10/10

Monday, 2 January 2012

Film #2 - Sherlock Holmes: A Game Of Shadows (2011)


After starting with the 2009 take on Sherlock Holmes, what better way to continue than with it's recently released sequel? While I know some may question why I would go to see this not much longer than 12 hours after I had rewatched and on the whole reslated the first one, I must admit that I only rewatched the first one because I already had plans set to see the sequel with friends. And might I say, what a sequel. This is how more blockbusters should follow themselves up, rather than trying to edge itself out to new risky ground it simply focused in on what the first did best. They've ramped up the action, the stakes and even the bromance between Holmes and Watson. I was more than relieved to see that the filmmakers had mainly admitted that they couldn't do the cold and calculated mystery solving side of Sherlock even half as well as Steven Moffat recently has for the BBC leaving us with a far more action orientated and impressive setpiece boasting piece of cinema. Oh, and by far the greatest improvement on the first one? The new cast addition of Jared Harris as Sherlock's infamous rival Moriarty. Managing to equally display menacing and genius at the same time, the cold calm Harris always managed to hold made him perhaps the only bit of casting I would dare compare to the BBC's series opposite. I can only urge those who like me, felt more than a little disappointed in the first attempt to give this Hollywood adaptation one more shot.

7/10

Sunday, 1 January 2012

Film #1 - Sherlock Holmes (2009)


Beginning this year of films, films and more films is the 2009 adaptation of Sherlock Holmes. If there's one thing that I don't like about this film, it's that it tries to call itself Sherlock Holmes. Other than that it's a fun blockbuster mystery romp with quite a strong lead cast delivering good performances. Robert Downey Jr seemed to play very much a victorian era Tony Stark, which as fun a performance it may be was not Sherlock Holmes. He was much too flirtatious and his humour was far too slapstick. Mark Strong (the man who seemed to be on a mission to be in every film of 2011) meanwhile delivered a menacing character as Lord Blackwood, a man of magic and cults. This leads me onto my other problem, the main plot idea was all over the place. The film couldn't seem to set it's mind on whether it wanted to be logical or all occult nonsense which grew really very tiresome very fast. Now, I want to keep these reviews pretty short and sharp so I'll sum this up now. If you're looking for a fun romp through ye olden days with a likable cast and some impressive visuals, sit down in front of this and enjoy yourself! If you're looking for a good modern day adaptation of Sherlock Holmes, please turn to the far superior BBC Series starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman.

5/10